Half Moon Bay Association, Inc.
Drainage Committee Report
Andrew Cecil and Alice Crandall
October 27, 2010
During the Special Meeting of the Half Moon Bay Association on July 29, 2010, the Board heard discussion from several owners regarding drainage and beach erosion issues affecting the complex. In response, the Board appointed Andrew Cecil to chair a committee to examine the drainage issues and propose solutions for further consideration. Alice Crandall volunteered her assistance and serves as the only other committee member. During the month of August 2010, the committee worked to examine the issue, discuss the problems with local county officials, and determine the best options for mitigation. The following report is based on the drainage study and those discussions. The report will proceed with a general discussion of stormwater runoff to make certain there is a minimum level of understanding of the principles of drainage and runoff before the issues are discussed as they specifically affect Half Moon Bay. The report outline is as follows:
Stormwater Runoff Basics (Ground Cover, Soil Types, Antecedent Moisture Conditions, Topography, Rainfall Intensity, and Duration)
Stormwater System Basics (Collection, Conveyance, and Discharge)
The Existing Stormwater System as Half Moon Bay (Current System and Proposed Modifications)
Project Priority and Cost Estimates
Stormwater Runoff Basics
Precipitation occurs in a variety of events with which we are all familiar. Precipitation can occur as rain, snow, sleet, hail, or a combination. Although Lake Norman does experience all precipitation events from time to time, it is the heavy rain events that create erosion issues and it will be these precipitation events on which this discussion will focus. Snow melt will eventually runoff, as does rain water, but snow and ice melt usually occur fairly slowly and are less of an issue than intense rain. If success can be achieved in devising drainage controls for rain events, the snow and ice events will be addressed as well.
Once rain hits the earth, it will either be absorbed into the ground or it will accumulate and move in a direction as a response to gravity, i.e., it will flow downhill. Whether the water is absorbed or runs off is a function of the soil type, ground cover, ground slope, rainfall intensity, and the condition of the earth’s surface prior to the rain event (the antecedent moisture condition).
Ground cover can be asphalt pavement, concrete, roofs, yards, landscaped areas, or wooded areas. The ground slope can be flat, gently rolling, or very steep. Intuitively, the propensity for water to accumulate and runoff is greater for impervious surfaces like pavement and roof tops than it is in yards or wooded areas. Further, runoff is more likely to occur on steep terrain than on flat terrain. Finally, runoff is more likely in a storm event that deposits six inches of rain in an hour as compared to an event that deposits one-eighth of an inch of rain in an hour.
In areas where there is a natural ground cover like yards, landscaped areas, and wooded areas, the soil type is an important parameter for the quantities of runoff which will occur during a rain event. Soils are generally a product of the decay of the parent rock which underlies the soil. For example, sandstone bedrock will decay to form sandy soils, and limestone bedrock will decay to form a soil with high clay content. There are of course exceptions such as alluvial soils or other comingled soils brought together by erosion. The inclusion of a discussion of these soils will tend to further complicate this discussion. Upper horizon soils like topsoil are created from the decay of organic material (animals and plants) which mixes with natural soils over long periods of time.
The foregoing generalization of soil types is important because all dirt is not created equally in the context of stormwater runoff. Some soils tend to naturally absorb rain water better than other soils. A good example can be seen in coastal areas of the Carolinas and in parts of Florida. Whereas most dwellings around Lake Norman have gutters and downspouts to collect and control rain water, houses in coastal areas rarely have gutters and downspouts because the naturally sandy soils and flat terrain absorb water quickly. By contrast, soils around Lake Norman do not absorb water easily and the roof water is collected and hopefully directed to some location where it will not misbehave.
In addition to ground cover type, steepness of terrain, and soil type, the antecedent moisture ground condition is significant in determining how much rain water will runoff. The antecedent ground condition means the condition of the ground before the rain event. The ground can be saturated or partially saturated from previous events, it can be dry, or in the worst case, it can be frozen. Saturated or partially saturated soils before a rain event mean that there will be little or no absorption into the ground from additional rain. Dry ground indicates that there will be absorption, and frozen ground behaves like pavement.
When rain hits the ground, there will usually be some combination of absorption and perhaps runoff if the rain event is sufficiently intense. The rain that is not absorbed by the soil or infused in small depressions in pavements and other impervious surfaces will begin to accumulate as it flows downhill and form a “sheet” flow of water. Sheet flow is more evident when observing rain water as it runs across pavement. Although it is not always visually apparent, sheet flow will also occur over natural ground covers. It is easier to observe sheet flow of water over landscaped areas and wooded areas than in grassed areas, although it still occurs in grass.
The topography of the ground is also a factor in how rainfall will affect a given area. Topography is another broad topic with many variables, but this discussion will be confined to the topography of Half Moon Bay. Before the Catawba River was dammed and portions of the watershed flooded to create Lake Norman in the early 1960’s, the watershed consisted of the Catawba River and numerous smaller tributaries which fed the river. The tributaries consisted of both perennial streams (flowing year round) and ephemeral streams or drains which flow intermittently in response to natural runoff. The streams and drains, like the river itself, were created over geologic time by tectonics and erosion.
When the dam was constructed and the watershed partially flooded, the locations of the tributary streams and drains are now marked along the shoreline by coves and bays. Half Moon Bay is located in what is considered a cove where an ephemeral stream continues to flow from time to time.
Before the condominium complex was constructed and before any development occurred, the ephemeral drain most likely flowed in the area of the boardwalk and directly through the middle of what is now the beach. The original flow path is significant because without deliberate intervention though drainage and stormwater controls, the natural impetus of stormwater will be to continue to flow where it once flowed prior to any development activity. That is, across the beach.
The ephemeral stream that created what is now Half Moon Bay is still evident today on the property and can be observed between the HMB parking lot and the Preston Development in the vicinity of the sewage grinder station. The drain or stream is intercepted by a headwall and 36-inch diameter concrete drain pipe which conveys the flow to Lake Norman. On route to the discharge point, the drain makes two discernable turns to maneuver it across the property and into the Lake. The pipe outfalls into the Lake and can be observed under the dock.
The last pieces of the runoff equation are perhaps the most important. The rainfall intensity and rainfall duration are two parameters that dramatically determine the quantity of runoff generated by a storm event. As all dirt is not created equal, all storm events are not the same. A rain event can be quick and intense like a summer thunderstorm or long and intense like the rainfall generated by the remnants of a passing hurricane. These are the rain events that create runoff issues, erosion issues, and flash flooding issues. Rain events where a front sets in and deposits small quantities of rain over extended periods of time will ruin our outdoor activities, but will rarely cause serious erosion or runoff problems.
Stormwater System Basics
The purpose of any stormwater system is to capture and control stormwater and direct it to a location where it will cause the least amount of inconvenience. Inconvenience can be defined as nuisance issues like puddles of water or issues creating expense to correct like damage to structures or erosion. In the case of Half Moon Bay, the issue is beach and shoreline erosion that compromises the aesthetics and the function of the complex in which we all have invested.
A functional stormwater system consists of stormwater collection, stormwater conveyance, and stormwater discharge. Collection is the process of gathering the stormwater to one or more locations where a concentrated flow is achieved. Conveyance refers to the means by which the collected stormwater is moved or conveyed from one location to another. Discharge is the point, or points where the stormwater is ultimately discharged or released. If properly designed and constructed, a stormwater system should function during most rain events with little or no maintenance required and little or no residual damage. There are extreme rain events that occur on occasion for which no system will function successfully.
Collection usually occurs by utilizing the topography of the land or by grading the land to a suitable topography to enhance the flow of surface water. The water will predictably flow downhill and planning can occur accordingly to anticipate, if not control the location at which water will accumulate.
Conveyance of stormwater occurs by utilizing pipes, culverts, ditches, and drainage swales to direct or convey the accumulated water. Pipes are common and require little explanation. Pipes for the collection of sewage or for the conveyance of drinking water come in a variety of diameters beginning at about four inches. Pipe or culverts for stormwater conveyance should typically be no smaller than 12 inches although smaller pipes can be allowed in certain cases. Stormwate pipes are usually constructed of concrete, corrugated metal, or High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) which are the black pipes that are so common today.
A ditch is defined as an open conveyance channel where the width of the top of the channel is only slightly greater than the depth. For example, a ditch may be two feet wide at the top and one foot deep. Ditches are utilized along roads and in industrial applications where there is no pedestrian traffic. Ditches are not recommended for residential areas and will not be discussed.
A swale is a type of open channel where the width of the top of the channel is significantly greater than the depth. A swale may be five feet wide at the top, but only six inches deep. Swales are utilized in residential locations where the drainage appurtenance should be less conspicuous, can be easily maintained by mowing, and pose little danger of an accident to pedestrians. Swales can utilize a variety of linings depending on the quantity and velocity of design flow. Most swales utilize a grass lining because of the low flow velocities expected.
The Existing Stormwater System of Half Moon Bay
As this discussion continues, it will be beneficial to make directional references since there is no single site map that is sufficient to support this report. If one is standing at the pool and looking at the lake, the direction is generally west, hence the spectacular sunsets. North will be to the right behind the two bedroom units, south will be to the left, and east will be directly behind towards the parking lot. The Lake side will be considered the front and the parking lot side will be considered the back of the complex.
At Half Moon Bay, collection and conveyance of stormwater is required on all sides of the complex for a successful stormwater system. The only discharge issues on the property are on the west side (front) of the complex since the Lake is the ultimate depository all stormwater.
On the east and north sides of the complex where the parking lot is located, the collection of the stormwater is occurring very effectively and efficiently. The ground naturally slopes towards the parking lot which directs the flow from the adjoining grassed areas to the pavement. Once the flow reaches the pavement, the stormwater is controlled by the concrete curbing. The curbing then directs the water to several “collection” points where the water is then concentrated.
One point of concentration is located between the two buildings near Unit A (John Humphrey and Ronnie Broughton) which will be referred to as “Area A.” The second point of concentration is located at the south end of the parking lot near Unit P (Mike and Alice Crandall) and will be referred to as “Area B.” The third point of concentration is on the north side of the two bedroom complex and will be referred to as “Area C”. From these three points, the stormwater flows by a variety of means to ultimately reach the Lake. The conveyance and discharge from each point of concentration will be discussed separately addressing the conveyance method currently utilized and the function and issues of each conveyance and discharge method.
The drainage conveyance for “Area A” represents the primary drainage for the HMB complex. The conveyance conduits for “Area A” consist of a 36-inch diameter concrete pipe, two 15- inch corrugated metal pipes, a rip-rap lined swale beside the boardwalk with a grated inlet, a long rip-rap lined swale traversing the yard, and a 9-inch HDPE pipe buried under the long rip-rap lined swale. The long rip-rap lined swale and the 9-inch diameter HDPE pipe discharge directly on the beach as can easily be observed.
The primary conveyance channel for “Area A” is the 36-inch diameter concrete pipe which has been previously discussed. It is this pipe that attempts to redirect the original flow path of the stormwater that used to cross the property where the beach is now located. The concrete pipe flows from the headwall on the east side of the parking lot in a westerly direction towards the lake. At the rip-rap swale located beside the boardwalk the concrete pipe makes a junction at a grated drop inlet and turns southwesterly towards the dock. The pipe traverses the yard just east (behind) the rip-rap swale to a point east of the gazebo. The pipe then turns to the west again at a junction box (now covered) and discharges under the dock.
The stormwater collected from the parking lot for “Area A” is directed to a headwall where two 15- inch corrugated metal pipes collect the flow and convey the water to a point of discharge at the east end of the rip-rap swale located beside the boardwalk. The water then flows within the swale approximately 40 feet to a grated drop inlet. When the top of the inlet is not obstructed by debris, the water will drop through the top of the grate and enter the 36-inch concrete pipe. This rip-rap ditch beside the boardwalk also receives stormwater form various downspouts (roof drainage).
This current drainage configuration with the 15- inch pipe and the grated inlet present a number of problems that should be addressed. One of the most complex components of the stormwater system is the collection. Once the water has been successfully collected, it is a poor practice to release the water and then attempt to “recapture’ the stormwater. Whereas the headwall at the parking lot captures the water effectively into the two 15- inch pipes, the water is then released from the two pipes and there is an attempt to recapture the water with a relatively inefficient grated inlet.
The capacity of a grated inlet is a function of the total area of the openings in the grate and the depth of headwater over the inlet. Headwater is defined as the height to which water can pool over the inlet. The capacity of the inlet near the boardwalk is often compromised by the accumulation of debris which obstructs the openings. There have been occasions where the grate was completely clogged with leaves and other debris making the capacity of the inlet virtually zero, meaning no stormwater from the two 15-inch pipes can enter the 36-inch outfall pipe. Even if the grate is cleaned frequently, the openings can be obstructed in a matter of seconds during a large storm event when the
inlet is most needed to function correctly. When the inlet is obstructed during a large storm, the water cannot enter the 36-inch pipe as intended and the swale will overflow and the water will flow across the beach. This type of drainage failure is the most likely reason why the long rip-rap swale was constructed across the front yard. That is, to accommodate the failure of the grated inlet to recapture the stormwater released by the two 15- inch pipes.
The best remedy for the problem of the grate malfunction is to extend the two 15- inch pipes and deposit the parking lot water directly into the side of the inlet and eliminate the unlikely expectation that the water will enter the 36-inch pipe through the top of the grate. The top of the inlet may have to be removed and raised slightly to accommodate the two pipes. Once the pipes are extended, there is no reason to have the rip-rap swale near the boardwalk. In addition to removing a drainage material (rip-rap) typically used in industrial settings, this rip-rap is the perfect hiding place for snakes and other critters. The rip-rap can be removed, the extended pipes covered with soil, and the swale can be covered with sod. There are two detailed sketches that illustrate the recommended modifications to these drainage structures.
Once the 15- inch pipes are placed directly into the inlet, the clogging of the grate will no longer be an issue since there is no reliance on the integrity of the grate to allow the water to enter the system. Further, the probability of overflowing the grate is no longer an issue and there is a much diminished necessity for the long rip-rap swale traversing the yard.
It is my opinion that the rip-rap swale traversing the yard was placed in an effort to correct the problem of the inlet overflowing during large storm events. When the grate surcharges and overflows, the long rip-rap swale was placed to intercept the overflow water and carry it away from the main part of the beach. If the 15-inch pipes are placed directly into the inlet, there is no chance the grate will overflow.
Even if the inlet overflows from time to time, there is no reason why the swale needs to be lined with rip-rap rock. Rip-rap rock is a very misunderstood and overused material. Rip-rap rock does not make water evaporate and disappear as many may believe. The function of rip-rap lined channels is to break up the energy of flowing water to prevent the scour (erosion) of the channel. Rip-rap linings are utilized in highway and industrial settings where large quantities of water are flowing at extreme velocities. If constructed correctly, the water will flow over layers of rock. The flowing water will never directly contact the soil that the rip-rap is trying to protect. Rip-rap rock is also used around the shoreline of the lake to break up the energy of wave action and therefore protect the shoreline against erosion.
The natural ground from the grate to the lake is a fairly gentle slope and the velocities of any water flowing in the swale (if any) will be fairly low. Therefore, there is no reason whatsoever to have a rip-rap channel lining in a swale where the velocities will not warrant the application. Not only is the rip-rap lined swale not necessary for the meager
velocities of water anticipated, the rip-rap swale across the yard is not even built correctly. If built correctly, there are layers of rock over which the water will flow. The flowing water must not come into contact with the soil it is protecting. The rip-rap swale across the HMB yard is just a pile of rocks placed over dirt. It is not a properly installed rip-rap channel. This channel is virtually useless, ineffective, and dangerous.
Not only is the rip-rap swale not necessary, it is also a safety hazard, especially to children and elderly people who may attempt to cross it to access the beach which is a common practice. Should someone lose their balance and fall into the rocks, lacerations or broken bones could easily result for which the Homeowners Association will be held liable.
While conducting research for this report, Alice Crandall solicited input from the Zoning and Land Development Departments for Mecklenburg County. Inspectors from the County visited the site and made the same observations as those related above regarding the lack of necessity for the rip-rap as well as the improper installation of the rip-rap if it were indeed required. I spoke with the County Officials during the inspection and there was concurrence with the opinions of the channel as expressed above.
Although the rip-rap or “pile of rocks” is not required in the swale, there is still the necessity for a small swale to intercept and control sheet flows of stormwater that will flow through the yard in large storm events. The swale will keep sheet flows from washing randomly across the beach. The recommendations for the rip-rap swale are to remove the rock, add topsoil, and place sod in the swale. The swale can be somewhat diminished in size and still function as required. The grass lined swale will be easy to maintain, more than adequate in capacity, and will remove a safety hazard (an unnecessary pile of rocks) from the premises. The elevation of the swale should be modified by raising the exit elevation 12 to 18 inches gradually as the swale progresses to the west (toward the lake) for reasons to be explained later.
There in an HDPE pipe of approximately nine inches in diameter buried under the rip-rap swale. The discharge end of the pipe can be seen at the beach. Since this pipe is buried, the full function of this pipe is not known. It is believed to accommodate the drain for the pool and to be a point of connection for several downspout drains from the three bedroom units. Since the full function of the pipe is unknown, it is proposed to leave this pipe as is, and raise the discharge end of the pipe 12 to 18 inches to enable the flow through this pipe to be redirected toward the dock as explained later in this report.
There was significant beach erosion this summer at the end of the rip-rap ditch. However, most of the water causing the erosion was not emanating from water intercepted by the the rip-rap ditch. Small quantities of water do enter the rip-rap ditch from sheet flows across the yard as previously discussed. During very large storm events when the grated inlet clogs, larger flows of water can travel down the rip-rap ditch.
There is also some erosion being created from the nine inch HDPE pipe intercepting roof drains.
Most of the water that creates beach erosion on a regular basis is actually coming from “Area B.” At the south end of the parking lot near the Crandall unit, the curbing directs stormwater to an outlet cut into the curbing. The water then travels overland in a swale and exits into the front yard. From here, the water travels through a grassed swale and eventually deposits this parking lot water into the western end of the rip-rap swale. From here, the parking lot water erodes the beach as was witnessed on many occasions this summer.
As the swale travels around the south end of the building, there is very little slope to enhance the flow of stormwater. After storm events, water will stand along the south end of the building providing a breeding ground for mosquitoes. The clay soil has very low permeability (absorption capacity) and this portion of the complex stays muddy much of the time.
To correct the problem with beach erosion caused from the drainage from “Area B” and to eliminate the muddy conditions and standing water on the south side of the building, it is recommended to capture the water at the end of the parking lot in a curb inlet with an attached basin. Since the parking lot water is well confined at this point, 100% of the water can be captured. The water will then be conveyed around the south end of the three bedroom complex via a 12- inch diameter HDPE pipe and safely deposited into the existing 36-inch concrete outfall pipe at a junction point which is currently buried.
The junction point consists of a makeshift manhole constructed of cinder block and is utilized to redirect the flow from the 36-inch pipe from a southwesterly direction to a westerly direction so the pipe can discharge under the dock. The junction box has a manhole cover on top which is also buried. There appears to be sufficient ground cover over the junction to access the manhole and drop the water from “Area B’ directly into the 36-inch pipe. Another small junction box will need to be added on top of the existing box. A manhole frame and cover can be placed on the new box for future access. The junction boxes can then be buried once again to keep the manhole cover out of the way.
When installing a 12-inch drainage pipe, the most expensive portion of the project is the trenching and backfilling, not the cost of the pipe as many believe. Material costs usually only account for 20%-25% of the total project cost. Advantage can be taken of the trench to install a second, 4-inch diameter perforated pipe near the top of the trench. The perforated pipe will be backfilled with clean, washed course aggregate or perhaps dredged pebble aggregate to allow the free flow of water from the top of the ground into the perforated pipe. Filter fabric will be utilized around the stone to keep the drain from clogging with soil. The 4-inch perforated pipe will be discharged into the 36-inch concrete pipe with the 12-inch drain pipe. A typical construction detail of the trench is included although the actual depth of the pipe is not known at this time. The trench depth will most likely vary from 24 inches to 36 inches depending on location.
The second option would be to grade the existing swale on the south side of the building to a grade steep enough to drain the parking lot without having the standing water. If this option is selected, the swale would need to be 15 to 18 inches deeper as it exits into the front yard. This portion of the swale is already very deep and an additional 18 inches would make the swale look like a canyon. The extra depth would need to be extended through the yard to a point where the grade of the new ditch intersects the existing ground. A ditch of this nature may create yet another hazard, one of tripping and falling in addition to being aesthetically objectionable. Further, the issues with the impervious soil would still leave a muddy condition on the south side of the building. A trench with a French drain and collection pipe, and perhaps a walkway would need to be considered since it may be difficult to grow grass with the limited sunlight in this location.
The greater problem with the second option would be the issue of having to recollect the stormwater somewhere else on the property in order to convey the water to a suitable discharge point. This is the same problem discussed at the grated inlet near the boardwalk. In the recommended option discussed above, the parking lot water can be totally captured as it exits the parking lot and conveyed to a suitable discharge point. If the water flows in an open swale across the yard, the water must be collected at another location where numerous other problems will occur. For the foregoing reasons, the second option is considered the least desirable.
“Area C” drains the accumulated water from behind the two bedroom units on the northwest side of the complex. There is an existing nine inch diameter HDPE pipe exiting at the beach just below the last two bedroom unit and it is assumed that this pipe drains surface and roof water from portions of the complex. Again, since this pipe is buried, the full function of this pipe is unknown.
At the northwest end of the parking lot, there is a small yard or landscaping inlet. It is assumed that this inlet eventually deposits water into the aforementioned nine inch HDPE pipe. It is also assumed that downspout drains deposit water into this pipe.
The investigation into the full function of this pipe is continuing as time allows.
It is certain that the small yard inlet is inadequate to accommodate significant stormwater flows. The small inlet currently utilized is adequate for landscape areas, but inadequate for the large flows from a parking lot. This inlet should be replaced with a standard grated inlet similar to the one near the boardwalk. If the grated inlet is sufficiently large and configured so that the grate is parallel to the flow, the grate should function adequately in this location.
If it is determined at the end of the drainage investigation that the 9-inch pipe is not a storm drain, then a 10 to 12 inch drain should be added to accommodate the drainage from the parking lot for Area C.
Thus far, collection and discharge of the parking lot flows (Areas A, B and C) have been addressed. Even when the recommended drainage controls are installed to correct the erosion caused by the parking lot drainage, there will still remain erosion issues around the beach and shoreline from sheet flows across the grass.
As an example, there are two primary points where erosion is evident in front of the three bedroom units. The deep erosion at the end of the rip-rap swale is primarily the result of parking lot drainage from Areas “A and “B” as has already been discussed. However, there is another point between the swale and the dock where erosion is occurring. This erosion is caused by sheet flows from the grass accumulating at a very subtle point and discharging over the bank. The water flows through and over the rip-rap along the shoreline and puddles on the beach before finding a path to the lake and leaving a channel of erosion. Similar sheet flow erosion occurs along most of the shoreline in front of the three bedroom units and the two bedroom units which are evident when the lake levels are low.
There is also shoreline erosion along most of the Half Moon Bay property where the land interfaces with the lake. While traveling the lake by boat, it can be observed that there are a number of methods that landowners utilize to control the erosion of the shoreline. Large rip-rap rock seems to be the method of choice, but there are more aesthetic options that are just as effective and efficient to install. Some shorelines are protected with crib walls, gabion walls, and MSE (Mechanically Stabilized Earth) walls. These walls are also known as segmental retaining walls and gravity walls. The MSE walls are the stackable split faced block walls that are very common in landscaping application due to the economy, aesthetics and ease of construction. These walls are also utilized in lieu of rip-rap rock to control the erosion along the shoreline.
Half Moon Bay could utilize an abbreviated form of these walls that will simultaneously control the shoreline erosion and effectively direct the sheet flow of water emanating from the yards. The proposal would be to install knee walls of approximately 24 inches in height from the sand beach southerly to the dock and from the sand beach northwesterly to the property line near the pine trees in front of Bayshore. The walls will be very short and cost effective for the numerous functions performed. They could be constructed during a time when the lake level is low such as the late summer or fall.
To place the walls, a shallow trench is excavated and a base of crushed stone is applied. The first course of block is placed on the base at whatever grade is specified in the designs. The cores of the block are filled with crushed stone for extra weight or ballast. Once the first course is completed, the remaining two or three courses are merely stacked on top (with ballast) and then a finished cap is applied.
The walls will function more effectively than rip-rap because of the self-battering construction method used for these walls. The walls naturally slope back and fill material can be extended from the existing bank to the back of the wall, an option not available for rip-rap since rip-rap is a flexible material. When the fill material is applied, the fill behind the walls will be graded to create a drainage swale to catch the sheet flow runoff from the yards. If possible, the walls and the swales behind the walls will be sloped very slightly to drain to a point where the water will do the least amount of damage. After the walls are constructed, but before the backfill is applied, the existing HDPE pipes mentioned above can be extended and placed behind the walls. By placing the pipes behind the walls, the pipes can be directed to a suitable place of discharge without the expense of trenching. A sketch detail is provided to illustrate the concept.
In front of the three bedroom units, the best place to discharge accumulated sheet flow water from the yard and from the HDPE pipe is at the dock near the 36-inch outfall pipe. The HDPE pipe which drains the pool and captures roof water can be extended behind the knee wall and discharged under the dock. The sheet flow water can be captured in the grass swale behind the wall and conveyed to a small basin near the dock (if elevations will allow) where it will drop to the lake level.
The HDPE pipe that services the two bedroom units and currently discharges at the beach can likewise be placed behind a similar knee wall to be built along the northern shoreline. The water from this pipe and from the swale behind the wall can be discharged at the end of the wall closest to Biscayne.
The proposed knee walls are a better and more cost effective option than placing rip-rap along the shoreline for a number of reasons. The knee walls serve numerous functions in addition to controlling shoreline erosion. The knee walls will provide a grassed swale behind the walls to control sheet flow and will provide a location to direct the HDPE drain pipes without the expense of trenching. The walls will be very low and stepping from the wall to the beach at any location will be safe and easy. Steps can be added in several locations if desired to make beach access available along the entire shoreline.
Aesthetically, the walls will frame the beautiful landscape of the property and enhance the value of the complex.
The last area to be addressed is the beach erosion occurring on the south side of the dock between the dock and Preston. After storm events, there is evidence of drainage from Preston crossing on to HMB property and eroding the beach. The best option to correct this issue is to add grassed swales and berms to direct the water away from the beach and force it to discharge closer to the property line. To prevent erosion of the yard, the swales and berms should be very subtle and grassed. A suitable area will have to be selected that receives sufficient sunlight to grow grass and to effectively divert the water. The landscape consultant for HMB should be consulted on the best location.
To solicit competitive pricing for any of the above phases, each contractor providing a bid has to be pricing the exact same project scope. Without a complete set of construction drawings, it is not possible to solicit pricing on any of the proposals set forth in this report. The estimates provided were derived without a set of working plans.
The drainage concepts discussed in the report utilize gravity to direct the water across the property and to a location where there will be no damage. However, there are very subtle elevation differences with which to work. Construction drawings cannot be completed until elevation surveys are conducted to make certain each proposal will function as intended. I can conduct the surveys when the owners feel they are willing to pursue some of these projects, but it is pointless to spend additional time until there is a commitment to build. In conclusion, estimated costs and a priority list is offered for the construction of the proposed facilities. Please be advised that all erosion issues on the property will not be eliminated until all individual projects discussed in this report have been completed.
Project Priority and Cost Estimates
Priority 1) Area B
Place curb inlet at the end of the parking lot, install 12-inch HDPE pipe (lined), install 4- inch perforated pipe with drainage stone, install stepping stones, extend pipes into 36-inch junction, and repair lawn. Estimated Cost $12,000 - $16,000
Priority 2) Modifications to the Rip-Rap Swale
Remove rip-rap rock from swale, apply top soil and sod, raise elevation of swale and existing HDPE pipe. Estimated Cost $5,000 - $6,000
Priority 3) Modifications to Swale and Grated Inlet beside Boardwalk
Remove rip-rap rock, extend existing 15-inch cmps and insert directly into inlet box, raise top of inlet if necessary, extend roof drains and insert them directly into inlet box, apply soil and sod. Estimated Cost $5,000 - $6,000
Priority 4) Divert Drainage from Preston
Construct berms and swales to divert overland flow of stormwater from Preston, apply sod to repair lawn. Estimated Cost $1,500 - $2,000
Priority 5) Replace Inlet Basin to Intercept Parking Lot Flow
Add grated inlet in place of landscape inlet. Estimated Cost $1,500
Priority 5) Construct Knee Wall in Front of Three Bedroom Units
Construct knee wall in front of the existing shoreline bank, extend existing HPDE pipe behind wall to discharge point near dock, backfill wall with clean stone and soil, construct swale behind wall, and apply sod. Estimated cost $7,000 - $9,000
Priority 6) Construct Knee Wall in Front of Two Bedroom Units
Construct knee wall in front of the existing shoreline bank, extend existing HPDE pipe from two bedroom units and Area C behind wall to discharge point property line close to Biscayne, backfill wall with clean stone and soil, construct swale behind wall, and apply sod. Estimated Cost $20,000 - $22,000
It should be noted that some cost benefits can be expected if several projects are undertaken at the same time due to reduced mobilization costs of the contractor. Further, no projects involving construction within the 760 foot elevation buffer can occur without permits from the County and without permission from the Lake Management Authorities.
Respectfully submitted,
Andrew Cecil, Alice Crandall
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
A good way to prevent stormwater flooding and sediment pollution is to use effective curb inlet filters.
ReplyDelete-Jay